Following Supergirl's disappointing box office performance, a new report has put fresh attention on James Gunn's future at DC Studios, with sources claiming his current contract could expire as early as the end of 2026 or 2027. While nothing has been officially confirmed by Warner Bros. Discovery, the reported timeline has sparked renewed discussion about what lies ahead for the filmmaker leading the rebooted DC Universe.

Since taking over DC Studios alongside Peter Safran in 2022, Gunn has become the public face of the franchise's ambitious reset, overseeing an interconnected slate spanning films, television, animation, and gaming. With multiple projects already announced, the success of that long-term vision has remained under constant scrutiny.

The latest report doesn't suggest Gunn is heading for an immediate exit, but it does raise important questions about what happens when those contracts eventually come up for renewal. Here's what has been reported so far and why Supergirl has suddenly become part of the conversation.

According to The Hollywood Reporter, sources believe James Gunn and Peter Safran's current contracts as co-heads of DC Studios are set to expire either at the end of 2026 or 2027, although Warner Bros. Discovery has not publicly confirmed either date. The report also makes clear that there is no indication Gunn is being removed from his role or that the studio has decided against extending his tenure.

The reported contract window is drawing attention because Gunn and Safran are not traditional studio executives. Since taking charge of DC Studios, the duo has overseen virtually every aspect of the rebooted DC Universe, from greenlighting projects and shaping long-term story arcs to deciding which characters receive standalone films or television series.

That unique dual role means any future decision regarding their contracts could have implications not only for DC Studios' leadership but also for the creative direction of the interconnected universe currently taking shape. If Gunn and Safran indeed leave the studio, it could leave DC with yet another incomplete, failed shared-universe ambition.

Despite Supergirl falling short of box office expectations, DC Studios has publicly maintained confidence in its long-term strategy. Peter Safran recently told The New York Times that while the film did not perform as hoped commercially, it represents just one chapter in a much broader plan for the DC Universe.

The reported contract window stated by The Hollywood Reporter has nevertheless attracted attention because it could coincide with several major DC releases, including Clayface and Man of Tomorrow, the latter of which Gunn is directing. If the reported timeline proves accurate, Warner Bros. Discovery will eventually have to decide whether to continue with the leadership team guiding its current creative vision.

DC Reportedly Pitted James Gunn’s 'Supergirl' Cut Against Craig Gillespie’s Before Its Box Office Collapse

That decision, however, is unlikely to depend on contract dates alone. Much of the recent discussion surrounding Gunn's future stems from the behind-the-scenes challenges that reportedly surrounded Supergirl long before it reached theaters.

According to the same Hollywood Reporter report, Supergirl encountered a difficult post-production process, with director Craig Gillespie and DC Studios reportedly taking different creative approaches as the film evolved. The outlet reported that separate cuts of the movie were assembled and screened for test audiences before the studio ultimately moved forward with its preferred version.

Supergirl has struggled to gain momentum since its theatrical debut. The film opened to $37.1 million domestically and has grossed roughly $89.1 million worldwide so far against a reported production budget of $170–180 million. Industry estimates generally suggest that a film of that scale would likely need to earn well over $400 million worldwide to comfortably break even once marketing and distribution costs are factored in, placing the DC release well behind that benchmark.

Its critical reception has also been mixed. While Milly Alcock's performance as Kara Zor-El has drawn praise from many reviewers, critics have pointed to issues with the film's pacing, storytelling, humor, and villain. The movie currently holds a B- CinemaScore, and according to The Hollywood Reporter, internal test screenings largely remained in the 60s, with the highest reported score reaching only 70, reflecting the creative challenges the project faced before release. The studio has since addressed the film's commercial performance, offering its own perspective on the box-office results.

Though unlike many studio executives, Gunn occupies a uniquely visible role at DC Studios. In addition to overseeing the wider DC slate alongside Safran, he continues to write and direct films himself while frequently engaging with fans online, making the performance of each project closely associated with his creative leadership.

With projects like Clayface, Man of Tomorrow and several new DC television series still moving forward, the next few years are likely to play a much bigger role in shaping Gunn's future than contract speculation alone. For now, the reported expiration dates simply add another layer of intrigue to an already pivotal period for the DC Universe.

Did 'Supergirl' Flop? Why Female-Led Superhero Movies Aren’t Working Anymore

Do you think James Gunn should continue leading DC Studios beyond his current reported contract, or is it time for a new direction? Let us know in the comments!