True crime documentaries often arrive polished, shaped carefully for maximum emotional impact. But every once in a while, a story surfaces that feels far less manufactured and far more unsettling because of it. The case at the center of The Perfect Neighbor is one such example, unfolding not through dramatic reenactments but through chilling real-world fragments that piece together a community tragedy.

As viewers lean closer to understand how it all spiraled, one behind-the-scenes revelation makes the story even more haunting: what if this movie was never meant to be a movie?

Geeta Gandbhir's thoughts on The Perfect Neighbor highlight the project's odd beginnings.

She shared, "It was never meant to be a film. It was just what the police happened to gather."

This fits how the documentary came together, pieced mostly from body-cam videos, emergency calls, and monitoring clips gathered by the Marion County Sheriff’s Office during the probe into the 2023 deadly shooting of Ajike “AJ” Owens in Ocala, Florida. 

Diving deeper into the materials, Gandbhir noted, "We received the body camera footage; it was acquired by the lawyer for the case." News outlets report that lawyers tied to the matter pursued detailed discovery and document requests, uncovering extensive police videos that captured earlier clashes between Owens and Susan Lorincz.  Ultimately, turning the tragedy into truth.

She also broke down the legal route to the files, explaining, "Once they had filed the Freedom of Information Act and used that to get the materials released, they became public record." Florida's wide-reaching open-records rules, known as 'Sunshine Law' measures, let much of the police content go public once probes hit key points. 

On what grabbed the team most, Gandbhir said, "With this, what was really incredible to us was the buildup, the slow buildup to the murder, and also we saw the community as they were before." That mirrors the recorded sequence: authorities fielded several calls to the Ocala area about squabbles involving Owens’ kids and Lorincz in the months leading up to the June 2023 event. 

Netflix’s 'The Perfect Neighbor' Ending Explained: Inside the Bloody Susan Lorincz Horror

Beyond The Perfect Neighbor in the Documentary Feature Film category, this year's Oscar Documentary Short Film nominees pack a punch with varied vibes.

The 2026 Best Documentary Short Film lineup is anything but one-note, blending frontline journalism with deeply personal storytelling. All the Empty Rooms explores the quiet aftermath of trauma through an intimate observational lens, while Armed Only with a Camera: The Life and Death of Brent Renaud honors the fallen journalist with a portrait that doubles as a meditation on the risks of bearing witness in war zones.

On a more experimental note, Perfectly a Strangeness uses striking imagery and minimal narration to reflect on humanity’s place in the universe, giving the category an arthouse edge. Elsewhere, Children No More: “Were and Are Gone” turns its focus toward remembrance and activism, documenting efforts to memorialize young lives lost to conflict.

Together, this year’s nominees highlight the documentary branch’s continued appetite for urgent real-world subjects balanced with bold formal choices, proving the short form remains one of the Oscars’ most emotionally potent arenas. Geeta Gandbhir's reveal that The Perfect Neighbor stemmed from unintended police files rather than planned filmmaking adds raw authenticity to its Oscar nod.

Where Was 'The Perfect Neighbor' on Netflix Filmed? Location, Set, and Everything You Need to Know 

What do you think about The Perfect Neighbor's origins and Oscar buzz? Let us know in the comments.