'Stranger Things' Papa Matthew Modine Blasts Off Series Finale With A Single Word

Published 02/08/2026, 9:23 PM EST

After nearly a decade of Demogorgons, heartbreak, and Hawkins chaos, Stranger Things officially wrapped up its run in December. But instead of a victory lap, the final season has found itself surrounded by heated debate, with many fans questioning whether the show stuck the landing.

While viewers have been loudly sharing their disappointment online, it turns out the backlash has not been limited to the fandom alone, because even Matthew Modine, who is someone closely tied to the series is now fueling the conversation in a big way.

Matthew Modine’s reaction to the Stranger Things Finale sparks major buzz

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

The finale discourse gained fresh momentum after Matthew Modine, who played the chilling Dr. Martin Brenner (Papa), weighed in on the ending in the most blunt way possible.

Responding to a fan comment on Instagram asking whether he liked the Stranger Things series finale, Modine did not hold back.

“Nope,” Matthew Modine replied.

Netflix and the Duffer Brothers decided to drop the finale of the flagship series in not one or two but three different volumes. Expectations rose to Eiffel Tower proportions; the reaction, when it came, suggested the drop. Even Matthew Modine, who spent four seasons terrorizing Hawkins with conviction, needed only one word to register the disappointment. When a villain stops monologuing, you know something’s gone wrong.

‘Stranger Things: Tales From ’85’ Cast – Meet the New Faces Entering Hawkins

 While his disapointment in the series' ending has become an Instagram popular spectacle, Matthew Modine character's conclusion has stirred out quite the opposite reaction from the actor.

Matthew Modine on Papa

Despite sparing only a single-worded rejection in the direction of Stranger Things' finale, it seems that Matthew Modine's disapproval is not rooted in the way his character met his end. When the actor was questioned about the 'what ifs' regarding his character he had quite the philosophical answer.

“What if you never died?” the actor gave a surprisingly reflective answer instead of leaning into the drama.

 “Everything dies. The moment you accept this, inevitably is the moment you truly begin living and become present.”, he responded

That comment suggested Matthew Modine was not upset about Papa being killed off in Season 4 but rather had issues with the finale itself.

Interestingly, he also made it clear that his criticism does not mean he is done with the Stranger Things universe. When another fan asked,

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

“If they asked you to go back on Stranger Things, would you?” Modine replied without hesitation: “Of course.”

His responses have added a new layer to the finale debate, leaving fans even more curious about what exactly did not work for him.

Why is Joe Keery Not Voicing Steve in ‘Stranger Things: Tales From ‘85'? Who is The Voice Actor Playing Him?

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

What did you think of the Stranger Things finale and do you agree with Matthew Modine’s reaction? Let us know in the comments! 

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :

ADVERTISEMENT

Karishma Dasgupta

36 articles

Karishma is an entertainment journalist at Netflix Junkie. She enjoys digging deep into stories and bringing clarity to the often fast-moving world of entertainment. She holds a double Master’s degree in Fashion Business Management and Digital Marketing.

Edited By: Aliza Siddiqui

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

EDITORS' PICK