Netflix is back with yet another spine-chilling crime documentary series. This time, Should I Marry a Murderer presents an eerie real-life scenario involving Caroline Muirhead, sharing a story of love and deception with the audience that takes on a sinister twist. This plot is carefully constructed with mystery and drama to hint at some shocking discovery while withholding certain facts. It also deeply explores relationships, secrets, and the chilling possibility that someone close may not be who they seem. 

What begins as a seemingly ordinary relationship takes a chilling turn when one confession shatters everything in Should I Marry a Murderer?

What appears to be an average relationship turns out to be much more sinister due to the groundbreaking revelation by a woman’s fiancé. It all began after Caroline Muirhead met the outdoorsman named Alexander "Sandy" McKellar and fell deeply in love. Soon after the couple got engaged, McKellar broke the horrifying news upon Muirhead's own questions. Three years prior, he had killed a cyclist with his twin brother, Robert. Scared, the two then buried the body on their farm.

They also managed to hide this crime from all those around until recently, when everything came crashing down. Eventually, Caroline discovered that the cyclist was named Tony Parsons. 

Additionally, McKellar asked for her help to move the body. Even though she was in dilemma, realizing that she must do something, she helped her then fiancé, but also put down a mark on the grave and alerted the authorities. As a result, both McKellar and his twin ended up being arrested. However, they were soon released as there was not enough evidence against them. 

The Best Netflix Documentaries of 2026: True Crime, Music, and More

Now, what makes this already chilling true story even more unsettling is how Netflix transforms it into a gripping and bone-chilling narrative. 

Netflix is well-known for its compelling true-crime content through which they expose the dark side of human nature by drawing inspiration from actual events. The recent true-crime docu-series, Should I Marry a Murderer?, emphasizes emotions, suspense, and psychological aspects of the story rather than merely describing the crime. The uniqueness of this story lies in the fact that it combines elements such as love, betrayal, and ethical dilemmas.

To make it more authentic, Josh Allott, the director of the documentary series, has included exclusive interviews with Caroline Muirhead, her family, friends, and the case's attorneys and investigators. An unseen video from Muirhead's personal life is also included in the three-part series. Furthermore, Netflix has enhanced the story with carefully constructed interviews and truthful recreations. 

Overall, Should I Marry a Murderer? proves that even in normal relationships, the truth is far from obvious. By presenting such a brave and tough protagonist as Muirhead, the series makes one realize the importance of trusting people, being aware of their true character, and voicing concerns regarding any issues that arise. Additionally, the way the case is shown on Netflix creates a sense of realism and emotional impact in the audience.

7 True Crime Documentaries So Chilling You Won’t Look Away

Hence, can love survive when the truth behind it is more terrifying than imagined? Let us know in the comments.