The streaming landscape has shifted as Reality Check: Inside America’s Next Top Model officially claims the peak position on the Netflix charts. It masterfully uncovers the psychological toll and controversial production tactics that defined the original series for over twenty-four cycles. This cultural surge has placed the documentary at the forefront of the national conversation, signaling a massive shift in how viewers consume reality nostalgia.

As audiences flock to witness the unfiltered truth behind the runway, the series continues to dominate the digital landscape despite mid-ratings. 

  As per Flix Patrol, Netflix is currently dominated by Reality Check: Inside America's Next Top Model, which has officially secured the #1 spot on the charts. This gripping docuseries currently holds a perfect 100% rating on Rotten Tomatoes and a 6.5 rating on IMDb. The show proves that even with a mediocre audience rating, the sheer power of viral nostalgia can propel a series to the absolute peak of the charts.  

The series explores the toxic atmosphere and controversial production tactics of the original series through modern interviews with Tyra Banks and former contestants, and how it affected the mental health of its young participants.

By blending archival footage with raw emotional testimonies, the series has successfully captured the attention of both nostalgic millennials and curious Gen Z viewers, as revealed in the top 10 TV Shows chart published by Flix Patrol.

Despite the extensive cast of returning judges, including Miss J. Alexander and Jay Manuel, the first supermodel, Janice Dickinson, is notably absent from the production. Director Daniel Sivan confirmed that while they wanted her participation, she was unfortunately unavailable due to prior filming commitments for another documentary. 

'Reality Check': Tyra Banks Confronts 'America's Next Top Model' Legacy

Reality Check: Inside America's Next Top Model soars the first spot, the television rankings for February 18, 2026, show a diverse mix of gritty documentaries, returning dramas, and competitions.

According to Flix Patrol, following the top-rated modeling expose, the psychological thriller Raw holds the second position after only one day on the platform. The Hunting Party maintains strong momentum at number three, proving that viewers remain hungry for intense, serialized storytelling.

The middle of the pack features a blend of romance and late-night reporting that keeps audiences engaged for hours. Love Is Blind Season 12 continues to draw fans in its fifth day of release, while Katt Williams: The Last Report remains a staple at number five. Long-standing favorites like The Lincoln Lawyer and Bridgerton continue to show remarkable staying power, occupying the sixth and seventh spots, respectively.

Rounding out the list are shows that delve into dark history and unfamiliar territories. The true-crime docuseries Jeffrey Epstein: Filthy Rich has seen a resurgence in popularity, currently ranking at number eight. The top ten is completed by the mystery series, HIS & HERS, and the new drama Unfamiliar, which has been steadily climbing the ratings for nearly two weeks. With its sharp cultural lens and addictive behind-the-scenes drama, Reality Check: Inside America's Next Top Model proves that even a mid-rated revival can strike a high-impact pose on Netflix’s global stage.

3 Reasons 'America's Next Top Model' Documentary on Netflix is A Must Watch This February

What do you think about topping the Reality Check: Inside America's Next Top Model Netflix chart? Let us know in the comments.