Casting alchemy became Stranger Things magic, transforming smart choices into cultural lightning rather than routine ensemble work. Millie Bobby Brown, Sadie Sink, Jamie Campbell Bower, and Winona Ryder shaped that success, now echoed by The Boroughs.

If the idea of a misfit crew of retirees in a New Mexico community facing off against supernatural forces did not excite audiences, the ones playing the misfit crew will surely do the job. 

A seasoned screen force with credits ranging from Raiders of the Lost Ark to Spider-Man 2, Alfred Molina anchors The Boroughs emotionally.

Sam, a recent widower and outsider, first witnesses the supernatural threat and emerges as an unlikely leader determined to protect his fragile new community.

An Academy Award-winner celebrated for The Accidental Tourist, Thelma & Louise, and A League of Their Own, Geena Davis brings authority to Renee. The sharp-witted resident supplies backbone and dry humor, grounding escalating danger with experience, skepticism, and a refusal to be underestimated.

With four Emmy Awards and an Academy Award nomination, Alfre Woodard lends credibility and gravitas. Judy operates as the group’s strategist, defined by civic loyalty and foresight. She becomes one of the earliest believers in Sam’s claims, recognizing the existential threat facing their town.

Best remembered as the resolute President in Independence Day and later for The Sinner, Bill Pullman plays Jack, an active investigator. Jack thrives on curiosity and persistence, often placing himself closest to danger while probing the unsettling patterns behind the community’s unexplained events.

“I'M JUST A TROLL"- 'Stranger Things' 5 Matthew Modine Makes a Surprising Confession with Return Hints

Renowned for portraying Lester Freamon on The Wire, Clarke Peters brings quiet authority to Art. Observant and methodical, Art counters louder personalities with logic and memory, offering historical context and pattern recognition crucial to understanding the town’s long-buried secrets.

Denis O’Hare as Wally A genre stalwart from American Horror Story and True Blood, Denis O’Hare embodies Wally. Integral to the core group, Wally is expected to contribute eccentric insight and unconventional skills, reinforcing the series’ blend of character-driven tension and supernatural unease.

With a cast built on range, restraint, and lived-in authority, the series positions itself as character-first science fiction rather than spectacle alone. As hinted by The Duffer Brothers, The Boroughs signals that unease, dread, and carefully sustained tension remain very much alive.

The Duffer Brothers Are Planning to Keep the Frights Coming on Netflix Even as 'Stranger Things' Bids Farewell

Which cast member of The Boroughs is your favorite? Let us know in the comments!