The lengths one would go to hide their own lies seems to be immeasurable, and the Sherri Papini story is the best example of that. A story that might lead you to doubt victims of crime from now on, asking if their ordeal was real or something made up or self-inflicted. The whole ordeal has been a matter of great interest to fans, and that is exactly why it inspired not one but two prominent documentaries.

The burning question is regarding the whereabouts of both documentaries’ streaming location, especially if they are on Netflix.

No, neither of the documentaries is on Netflix. The very first documentary made on Sherri Papini’s baffling story was Perfect Wife: The Mysterious Disappearance of Sherri Papini, which premiered on June 20, 2024, on Hulu. However, currently, the documentary is available on Disney+ for streaming. The second one is Sherri Papini: Caught in the Lie - Season 1, which is streaming on Discovery+, HBO Max, HBO Max Amazon, and the Discovery+ Amazon Channel.

Perfect Wife: The Mysterious Disappearance of Sherri Papini dealt with the overall incident that took six years to unfold. Papini's now-ex-husband, Keith, his sister Sheila Koester, Papini's best friend Jennifer Harrison, Shasta County sheriff Kyle Wallace, FBI special agents Denis Farmer, Courtney Lannto, and Peter Jackson, among others, are interviewed for the three episodes of Hulu's limited series.

On the other hand, Sherri Papini: Caught in the Lie - Season 1 mostly presents Papini’s side of the story. The four-part docuseries features interviews with experts and Papini herself, who did not participate in the 2024 documentary but takes this one as an opportunity to explain the incident and its proceedings from her perspective.

‘Someone Has To Know’ Netflix Cast: Meet the Characters of Streamers Latest True Story Crime Thriller

When one learns about the web of lies and drama that happened in the Sherri Papini case, they would understand true crime fans' obsession with it.

The real story started with Sherri  Papini going on a run. After going for a run close to her Redding, California, home, Sherri Papini, a wife and a mother of two, was reported missing in November 2016. According to a criminal complaint filed in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of California, she reappeared after 22 days by the side of a highway on Thanksgiving Day, 146 miles south of where she had first vanished.

She claimed that two women had abducted her and left her with bruises and handcuffs. Papini stuck to her story for six years. However, after receiving more than $30,000 from the Victim Compensation Board following her disappearance, Papini was accused of 34 charges of mail fraud and one case of making false claims in 2022. To know her motive and the end result, one has to go watch the two documentaries.

What Is Deanna Thompson’s Documentary Dont F**K With Cats All About? Where Can You Watch It in 2026?

Did you know about the Sherri Papini story? If yes, did you find it to be similar to a crime thriller script? Share your thoughts.