Sabrina the Teenage Witch has been spellbinding audiences for decades, casting a nostalgic charm that blends teenage troubles with a pinch of magic. For those who grew up wishing their family photo albums included a talking cat, Sabrina Spellman was the ultimate supernatural role model. But if you thought Netflix would be the perfect coven to host her classic antics, a bit of digital wizardry is needed to track down where she has cast her streaming spells.

If growing up with Sabrina has taught the audience anything well enough, it was that sometimes, the magic lies not in the spells but in knowing exactly where to stream them.

The 1996-2003 running Sabrina the Teenage Witch has not been conjured up on Netflix. Instead, the show simmers quietly and exclusively on Hulu, the cauldron for many classic television fans seeking nostalgia alongside newer hits. However, Netflix is not left out of the magical equation, hosting its own dark sorcery tale: the Chilling Adventures of Sabrina, a reboot with a distinctly spookier vibe that has bewitched a whole new audience.

Comparing the two Sabrinas' witchcraft is like mixing potions with very different recipes. Melissa Joan Hart’s 90s beloved sitcom served a light-hearted, family-friendly spell of laughter and teenage woes sprinkled with a touch of magic. Meanwhile, Netflix’s Chilling Adventures of Sabrina, led by Kiernan Shipka, shifts to a shadowy incantation featuring dark rituals and mysteries that even quite serious witches would raise their eyebrows at, the less homework, more horror backing. 

Is 'One-Punch Man' Season 3 Coming to Netflix? When and Where Can You Watch It in the USA in 2025

Sabrina may be the same witch we talk about, but not exactly the xerox from streamer to streamer. Netflix seems to have its own set of sorcery to perform when it comes to Sabrina's macabre.  

While she may not be 30 years old enough to be the Halloween favorite this season, the Netflix reboot of Sabrina does earn points for bringing a fresh twist while paying a stylish homage to witchcraft lore. Its atmospheric scenes and layered characters offer a spellbinding brew for fans of supernatural drama and horror alike. Though it may leave some enthusiasts of the original yearning for some lighthearted laughs, the Chilling Adventures of Sabrina holds strong as a modern cult classic that delves deep into Sabrina's not-so-typical sweater vest magic.

If it is the cozy, goofy charm of the original Sabrina that overtakes the coveting, Hulu is the magical gateway to it. But for a bewitching plunge into a horror-infused teenage witch saga, Netflix’s Chilling Adventures of Sabrina stands ready to cast a stronger spell over even Sabrina the Teenage Witch. No matter the platform, Sabrina Spellman’s charm proves timeless, and if we are talking about the 21st century version, a little magic never goes out of style.

Is 'Chilling Adventures of Sabrina' on Netflix? How to Watch This Must-Watch Halloween Special in 2025

Which of Sabrina the Teeange Witch's stream-spells are the best? Let us know in the comments below!