Did the Netflix ‘Monster: Ed Gein' Kill His Brother? How Many Victims Did He Really Have? A Complete Breakdown

Published 10/03/2025, 8:25 AM EDT

In the hushed farmlands of Wisconsin, where shadows linger longer than the sun, rises the terrifying tale retold in Monster: The Ed Gein Story. His farmhouse became a shrine of horrors, each corner echoing with unspeakable acts that carved his name into infamy. The Butcher of Plainfield did not simply kill; he reshaped nightmares into reality, staining history forever. Every detail drips with menace, every silence screams with terror. And still, fans shudder with one question: did he kill his brother?

The series spotlights convicted killer Ed Gein, blurring real-life horrors with reel-life retelling, while uncovering the people who tragically became his victims and the chilling legacy he left behind.

Unmasking Ed Gein: The brother’s death, hidden crimes, and the real victim count

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

Ed Gein was responsible for the deaths of two women: 54-year-old Mary Hogan, a local tavern owner, and 58-year-old Bernice Worden, a hardware store proprietor. Both reportedly resembled his mother. While he admitted to disturbing activities with corpses, no other murders were confirmed. Many speculate about his brother, Henry George Gein, but neither in real life nor in Monster: The Ed Gein Story did Gein ever harm him. 

After their father died in 1940, Ed Gein and his older brother, Henry Gein, took on odd jobs to support the family. During one task, a brush fire on their property spiraled out of control, leaving Henry Gein dead. Initially ruled an accident, the circumstances have sparked lingering speculation, adding another eerie layer to the unsettling history surrounding the Gein household. The film peels back the layers of horror, and fans remain curious to know if the director ever knew Ed Gein.

'Peaky Blinders' Spinoff Series Announced, Cillian Murphy Is Returning but With a Twist

Dive into Hollywood’s darkest curiosities and uncover whether legendary director Alfred Hitchcock ever crossed paths with Ed Gein, revealing a chilling connection that blurs the lines between real-life horror and cinematic genius.

Uncovering the relationship between Alfred Hitchcock and Ed Gein

It is widely speculated that Alfred Hitchcock and Ed Gein had a connection, largely because Hitchcock’s Psycho shares striking similarities with Gein’s life. The character Norman Bates mirrors Gein’s unusual relationship with his mother and fascination with preserved corpses. The Netflix series emphasizes this parallel, even portraying Hitchcock and author Robert Bloch discussing Gein’s crimes. However, there is no evidence that Hitchcock ever knew Gein personally. The film reportedly drew inspiration from his case, but the two men had no real-life connection.

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

Ed Gein’s life and crimes have influenced countless books and films, including Alfred Hitchcock’s Psycho (1960), The Texas Chain Saw Massacre (1974), and The Silence of the Lambs (1991). Yet, Netflix’s documentary Monster: The Ed Gein Story, featuring an exceptional cast that brings each chilling detail to life, has struck a deeper chord with audiences. Its haunting portrayal of Gein’s world immerses viewers in darkness, leaving them tense and unsettled, and ultimately curious to know the full truth about his victims.

Amidst AI Actor Controversy, 'Squid Game' Creator Makes a Whopping $3 Million Move for AI in Entertainment

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

Do you think Ed Gein was behind his brother's demise? Let us know in the comments below.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :

ADVERTISEMENT

Yusra Miraj Khan

1067 articles

Yusra Miraj Khan is an Entertainment Journalist at Netflix Junkie. Specializing in Taylor Swift and the British Royal Family, she transforms modern mythologies into high-ranking, reader-first narratives. Since joining in early 2025, Khan has penned over 500 articles, known for their sharp decoding of Easter eggs and PR silences.

Edited By: Itti Mahajan

ADVERTISEMENT

EDITORS' PICK