True crime documentaries have long fascinated audiences by combining meticulous investigation with compelling storytelling. Over time, they have even evolved into a cultural phenomenon, offering viewers an insightful look into the human psyche and the complexities of an offense. In 2025, The Yogurt Shop Murders joined this flourishing genre, promising yet another riveting and expertly crafted exploration of a real-life case that has captured attention for decades. Now, with some time passed since its release, the masses are eager to know if it is available to stream on Netflix.

So, does the streaming giant host the documentary, or is its digital home elsewhere, perhaps even behind an extra paywall?

The Yogurt Shop Murders, released in August on the small screen by HBO, quickly became a standout in the true crime genre. The miniseries spans one season of four hour-long episodes, dropped weekly when it premiered, though now available to stream together on HBO Max and not Netflix. Fans without a pre-existing HBO Max subscription must pay $9.99 a month to watch this gripping documentary, notably offered in English, Spanish, Polish, and Russian.

The Yogurt Shop Murders, for those unversed, brings to life the 1991 shocking tragedy that struck Austin, Texas, when four teenage girls were brutally murdered at a local frozen yogurt shop. The senseless crime left the community reeling, sparking grief, fear, and countless questions that lingered for years. Families and friends were left to cope with unimaginable loss until recently, when investigators claimed to have identified a dead suspect 34 years later, bringing the case to a close. Alternatively, while The Yogurt Shop Murders is not available on Netflix, the streamer’s vault for the genre is not exactly empty.

Netflix Greenlights Chilling Thriller Series Exploring a Twisted Father-Daughter Dynamic

Netflix houses countless true crime documentaries encompassing both solved and unsolved sagas, allowing its users an edge-of-the-seat experience.

Netflix continues to dominate the true crime genre with a compelling lineup. Love Con Revenge, a recent release, investigates romantic frauds, following victims, including a Tinder Swindler prey, as they uncover deception. The Real Bling Ring: Hollywood Heist revisits the infamous celebrity burglaries of Beverly Hills teens. American Murder: Gabby Petito chronicles the tragic case of a young vlogger’s murder. Conversations with a Killer: The Son of Sam Tapes explores David Berkowitz’s chilling crimes, while Amy Bradley Is Missing examines the long-unsolved disappearance of a young woman on a cruise.

Clearly, while The Yogurt Shop Murders remains just out of Netflix’s reach, the platform shows that true crime aficionados have more than one doorway into the shadows of real-life mysteries. From decades-old cases to recent headlines, Netflix’s offerings continue to captivate, challenge, and haunt viewers. For those fascinated by the intricate mix of human psychology, suspense, and tragedy, the hunt for the next gripping story is never over, and Netflix ensures it is always just a stream away.

6 Must-Watch Netflix Series Arriving This October, And They’re Not All Scary

Will you be watching The Yogurt Shop Murders on HBO Max or stick to what is available on Netflix? Do let us know in the comments.