Have you ever wondered what Christmas really is without its little mysteries? From what might lurk inside this year’s stocking hung at the fireplace to guessing who has been turning the cozy town of Fletcher's Grove into a crime scene, festive cheer often comes with a dash of intrigue this time of the year. Hallmark’s Mistletoe Murders is exactly where holiday spirit is mixed with the perfect pinch of unsettling puzzles. With season two wrapped, the riddle now is whether any clues remain for future crimes and if any more seasons will deliver more murderously merry escapades for Emily Lane to indulge in?

Who knew that decking the halls could involve dodging murder suspects? The odd new redheaded neighbour in town, of course. 

The big question on mystery enthusiasts' wish lists is simple: Will Mistletoe Murders get the green light for a third season? Sarah Drew, who plays Emily Lane, admitted on the Pop Culture Unplugged podcast that they are “just waiting on a season pickup.” Without Hallmark’s official nod, no new cameras could really roll. Drew even urged the audience to make as much noise as they can because "everybody listens".

The second season of the show unwrapped six episodes filled with festive chaos and murder mysteries. Emily Lane found herself sheltering a suspect while investigating a restaurant owner’s death. With Drew's both on and off-screen involvements, which she declared on Pop Culture Unplugged was her "favorite job", the season deepened Emily’s secretive backstory and complicated romance with Detective Sam Wilner. New characters and twists expanded Fletcher’s Grove’s fog of secrets and cozy suspense, keeping viewers guessing from snowflake to snowflake.

Taylor Swift’s Secret ‘Opalite’ Video Shoot Might Be the Christmas Plot Twist of the Year

Just when you thought Christmas was about cookies and carols, along comes a side of crime scenes.

It was in season one where viewers were introduced to Emily Lane, the plucky new owner of a Christmas shop with a knack for diving headfirst into suspicious circumstances. Murder had disrupted the town’s cheer, from hit-and-runs to the clever use of a Christmas Carol-themed scavenger hunt. Alongside Detective Sam Wilner, Emily’s sleuthing skills illuminated a path through the frosty haze, setting up a unique blend of holiday warmth and whodunit thrills that had the audience hooked.

Part of Hallmark's Christmas roster, Mistletoe Murders combines yuletide cheer with mystery merriment like no other. Though the fate of season three remains in Hallmark's hands, the cast’s enthusiasm and fan support might just sleigh the approval process. Until then, fans can cozy up with past seasons and hope for new festive enigmas in future Christmases.

‘Holiday Touchdown: A Bills Love Story’: Cast, Plot & Every Christmas Detail We Know So Far

Do you think Mistletoe Murders' presents under the Christmas tree have a third season in one of the boxes? Let us know in the comments below!