Why Did Andrew Garfield Drop Out of ‘Frankenstein’ 2025? Here’s Why Jacob Elordi Replaced Him

Published 11/08/2025, 11:42 PM EST

Frankenstein has already stormed theaters, lightning and shadows included, and fans everywhere were either swooning or side-eyeing the cinematic monster. Guillermo del Toro delivered his gothic grandeur, but the drama behind the scenes was equally juicy. Andrew Garfield exited, Jacob Elordi stepped in, and suddenly every X post, Reddit thread, and Instagram story became a debate over who truly owns the creature that terrified and mesmerized audiences this year.

While audiences gasped at the Creature’s first roar, the real shock brewed behind the scenes, where chaos, delays, and last-minute changes turned production into its own blockbuster drama.

Why did Andrew Garfield leave Guillermo del Toro’s Frankenstein?

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

Andrew Garfield’s departure from Frankenstein was less a plot twist and more a scheduling tragedy. The 2023 Hollywood strikes had thrown calendars into chaos, production schedules collided, and suddenly, one of the brightest stars in the industry could not make the filming dates. Garfield’s exit is not scandalous but a reminder that even magnetic actors cannot bend strike timelines or dodge industry logistics.

By the time filming resumed, Andrew Garfield was committed elsewhere. The strikes had rearranged Hollywood like a game of Jenga, leaving Garfield unavailable for del Toro’s monstrous vision. Timing, in this case, was crueler than any electrified creature, and fans had to brace themselves for someone new to step into the iconic role.

“He needed...”- Andrew Garfield Expresses Grave Sadness for Losing 'Frankenstein' to ‘Euphoria’s’ Jacob Elordi

As Garfield vanished into other projects, a new Creature roamed the screen. While fans debated loyalty, the role proved that sometimes the monster can be more thrilling than the actor who plays him.

Who replaced Guillermo del Toro’s Frankenstein?

Jacob Elordi took on the role of the Creature, injecting his own intensity and shadowed charm into Guillermo Del Toro’s gothic canvas. Andrew Garfield’s exit left a void, yet Elordi transformed it into a new heartbeat for the film. Audiences watched eagerly, curious whether this Creature would mesmerize or falter under the weight of expectations, and Elordi’s performance became one of the year’s most discussed cinematic shifts.

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

The ensemble only amplified the allure. Oscar Isaac as Victor Frankenstein, Mia Goth as Elizabeth, and Christoph Waltz in a pivotal role ensured that Guillermo del Toro’s vision was not just about horror. The film became a spectacle of obsession, artistry, and gothic drama, proving that even behind-the-scenes chaos cannot dim the lightning that strikes when talent converges on screen.

"F--- AI" - Guillermo del Toro Slams AI at Netflix's 'Frankenstein' Screening

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

What are your thoughts on Andrew Garfield’s exit and Jacob Elordi taking over the iconic role? Let us know in the comments below.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :

ADVERTISEMENT

Shraddha Priyadarshi

1162 articles

Shraddha is a content chameleon with 3 years of experience, expertly juggling entertainment and non-entertainment writing, from scriptwriting to reporting. Having a portfolio of over 2,000 articles, she has covered everything from Hollywood’s glitzy drama to the latest pop culture trends. With a knack for telling stories that keep readers hooked, Shraddha thrives on dissecting celebrity scandals and cultural moments.

Edited By: Aliza Siddiqui

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

EDITORS' PICK