The Boys Season 5 practically weaponised chaos, turning every episode into a fresh explosion of betrayals, gore, and unhinged twists. But the finale’s biggest punch came through Billy Butcher’s fate, the exact brutal ending comic readers had feared was coming for years. Still, Butcher was far from the only major shake-up, as the show completely twisted several huge comic book endings before taking its final bloody bow.

And as The Boys finally locks the fate of its characters, here are the 5 biggest changes made to the comic book ending.

One of The Boys Season 5’s biggest shocks came through the complete rewrite of Black Noir’s infamous comic book twist. In Garth Ennis’ original comics, Black Noir is secretly revealed as a clone of Homelander, created by Vought as a contingency weapon in case Homelander ever lost control. However, years of silently waiting drove Noir completely insane, eventually leading him to frame Homelander for several horrific crimes, including Becca Butcher’s a******, before pushing him toward a violent White House rebellion. The comic storyline later explodes with Black Noir m******** Homelander before Billy Butcher brutally smashes Noir’s skull apart with a crowbar.

Season 5, however, completely abandoned that nightmare twist. Instead, Homelander remained the show’s true monster from beginning to end, while Ryan Butcher carried much of the emotional tension tied to the final confrontation between Homelander and Butcher. And rather than k****** Black Noir, the finale transferred the comics’ infamous crowbar death directly onto Homelander himself, with Butcher brutally finishing him off in one last blood-soaked showdown.

Who is Ess Hodlmoser in 'The Boys' Season 5? Meet The Actor Behind Eleven Parody on The Superhero Show

However, not every comic change ended in disappointment, as The Boys Season 5 delivered one of its most brutally satisfying payoffs through The Deep’s fate instead.

Comic readers were blindsided the moment The Deep died in The Boys Season 5, especially because the comics originally kept him alive till the very end. But the series instead turned his downfall into pure cosmic karma. After m******** Black Noir II and spiralling deeper into madness, Deep unknowingly sealed his fate through the Alaskan oil disaster that k***** 1.4 billion marine animals, causing the entire ocean to turn against him. Episode 7 even warned him that the sea itself wanted blood the second he touched water again.

That warning exploded during the White House finale when Starlight finally confronted the man who assaulted her back in Season 1. Desperate for Homelander’s approval, The Deep foolishly believed he could defeat her, only for Annie to blast him straight into the ocean below. Seconds later, the sea ripped apart its former king. Marine creatures swarmed him before a giant squid violently pierced through the back of his head, delivering one of the franchise’s goriest and most satisfying deaths.

When talking about fear, how could comic lovers forget the exact brutal fate The Boys Season 5 ultimately handed to Billy Butcher?

Both the comics and the show end with Billy Butcher attempting to wipe out every Supe after Homelander’s death using the Supe Virus. However, the comics pushed Butcher into an even darker rampage after becoming consumed by paranoia and dissatisfaction following Homelander and Black Noir’s downfall. With the rest of The Boys already carrying Compound-V powers, Butcher eventually m****** Frenchie, Kimiko, and MM himself before Hughie Campbell finally ends him after a brutal fight at the Empire State Building.

The show, however, softened that massacre while still keeping Butcher’s descent terrifyingly intact. After Ryan rejected him, Terror died, and Stan Edgar revealed Vought would rise again, but Butcher fully snapped, believing another Homelander would eventually return. Still, unlike the comics, he never slaughtered the remaining Boys himself, with Frenchie instead dying earlier at Homelander’s hands in Episode 7. The finale also shifted Hughie and Butcher’s final confrontation from the Empire State Building to Vought Tower, where Hughie ultimately shoots Butcher instead of stabbing him like the comics.

And when it came to pure psychological horror, no character changed more brutally from the comics than Homelander himself.

Perhaps the show’s biggest rewrite never came through the ending itself, but through Homelander’s entire personality. Unlike the comics, which portrayed him as a reckless frat-boy psychopath constantly manipulated by Black Noir, the series transformed Homelander into a far more terrifying monster hiding behind fake godhood. Powered heavily by Antony Starr’s chilling performance, the live-action version carried deep childhood trauma, violent insecurity, mommy issues, and an obsessive hunger to be worshipped. And unlike the comics, where Black Noir secretly framed him for several atrocities, the show forced Homelander to fully own every horrifying act himself.

That difference completely exploded in the finale. After Billy Butcher, Ryan Butcher, and Kimiko Miyashiro stripped away his powers, Homelander’s entire macho facade instantly collapsed. The so-called god who spent five seasons terrorising the world suddenly turned into a trembling, whimpering coward begging for mercy seconds before Butcher crushed his skull apart with a crowbar.

And while Billy Butcher and The Boys succeeded in destroying monsters like Homelander, the finale’s darkest punchline revealed that the real machine behind the chaos never truly died at all.

In the original comics, Vought eventually faded into obscurity after rebranding into a different company, with superheroes slowly losing their grip on society. However, The Boys Season 5 completely rewrote that ending through Stan Edgar’s return. After quietly manipulating events from the shadows, Edgar reclaimed control of Vought International, making it clear the corrupt empire behind the Supes was still alive and preparing for another rise.

That twist ultimately became one of the show’s most cynical departures from the comics. Instead of ending the cycle, the finale suggested another Homelander-like figure could eventually rise again under Vought’s control, especially after Edgar openly promised to rebuild the company into what it once was. The ending also strongly hinted that Vought’s survival could continue shaping future spin-offs like Vought Rising.

And as The Boys finally closed its blood-soaked chapter, the finale ultimately proved that no one truly escaped unbroken, whether through Butcher’s terrifying downfall, Homelander’s pathetic collapse, or Vought’s survival beyond the chaos itself.

'The Boys' Season 5 Finale: 3 Characters Who Got Their Happy Ending And 3 Who Did Not

What are your thoughts on The Boys Season 5’s biggest comic book changes? Which finale twist shocked you the most? Let us know in the comments.