James Gunn has taken up the cape with all the confidence of a man who thinks Clark Kent should journal in lowercase. His Superman boasts David Corenswet in blue spandex and Rachel Brosnahan sharpening her wit as Lois Lane. A reboot meant to cleanse the Snyder-drenched palette, it promises a brighter tone, snappier newsroom repartee, and, mercifully, fewer messianic metaphors. Whether it delivers art or an after-school special, audiences are, at present, withholding judgment like Perry White’s editorial approval.

Instead of building anticipation, the sneak peeks and behind-the-scenes clips are sparking frustration. From on-set photos of Superman saving civilians to leaked footage of costumes and key locations, fans feel like they have already watched half the film. What was meant to fuel excitement is now being treated like a spoiler parade. Social media has turned into a meme battlefield, with comments asking if James Gunn is releasing the Blu-ray in weekly pieces.

James Gunn’s Superman might already be breaking DC records, but the backlash does not seem to stop. Many are still clinging to the cape of Henry Cavill, whose departure triggered a fandom-level identity crisis. Gunn’s brighter, cheerier tone feels jarring to viewers who spent a decade with a moody, near-Shakespearean Superman. Add in a few mid-budget-looking costumes and Lex Luthor’s bleach-blond reveal, and fans are rethinking what they signed up for.

‘Superman’ Takes Flight for a Cause With Free Screenings, Bringing Big Screen Wonder to Deserving Kids

Whether or not fans warm up to a different kind of Superman, few were ready for this level of pre-release exposure.

Fans have taken to social media to vent about the constant stream of Superman content emerging from the set. With every new image, teaser, or blurry on-location clip, they claim they have already seen half the movie, minus the popcorn and credits. While James Gunn’s enthusiasm is clear, some viewers say the slow drip of content is making the final product feel less like a cinematic event and more like an extended social media campaign.

Others have seized the moment to critique the tone of James Gunn’s Superman, describing it as overly cheerful or sanitized. Although comic book tradition has long painted Superman as a hopeful and principled figure, many fans have grown accustomed to Henry Cavill’s more brooding, emotionally restrained interpretation. For those who preferred their Clark Kent a little grimmer and gloomier, this brighter, classic version of the character feels like an unexpected return to form they were not prepared for.

There is no denying that anticipation around the new Superman is building steadily, but so is the skepticism. The combination of heavy pre-release visibility and a tonal shift from previous portrayals has created a unique situation for the reboot. Whether James Gunn’s vision will ultimately win fans over remains to be seen, but it is clear that DC’s most iconic hero is once again at the center of a very human debate.

Henry Cavill Superman Movies in Order: Complete Watch Guide

Are the constant Superman updates ruining the suspense for you too? Join the conversation in the comments.