Long before television flickered to life, the rich pages of comic books offered an escape into worlds where heroes rose beyond imagination. As these stories journeyed from paper to the silver screen, creative minds like James Gunn have shaped their evolution. Over time, the comic book realm, once a stronghold of straight male and female leads, opened its doors to a more diverse spectrum of characters. Now, Supergirl, one of the most relatable heroines, finds herself at the center of speculation surrounding her sexuality.

Will Supergirl break new ground in James Gunn's DC Universe? Former X-Men '97 showrunner sparks bold speculation about the heroine’s potential LGBTQ+ storyline.

In the comic book world, Supergirl’s romantic interests have traditionally been portrayed as straight. Yet, the upcoming adaptation dropped subtle hints that suggested a possible queer interpretation, though it never fully confirmed her s--uality. Now, bold speculation has ignited once again, thanks to Beau DeMayo. He took to his X account and posted a striking message about the upcoming 2026 Supergirl film. His words, “If that’s the vibe #supergirl will be a gay icon", have sent fans into a frenzy of theories.

Supergirl has long stood as a powerhouse in the comic book world, celebrated for her strength equal to Superman’s and admired by countless women who see themselves in her courage. While traditionally portrayed as straight, fans have begun questioning her s--uality, especially in modern media where queer female heroes shine. Though comic books pair her with men, the Supergirl series hints at a more nuanced, possibly queer, interpretation. Meanwhile, James Gunn, who is shaping the future of the DC Universe, has shared insights on his upcoming Superman film, revealing bold themes.

'Superman' Cast Net Worth: How Rich Are David Corenswet, Rachel Brosnahan, Nicholas Hoult and Others in 2025

James Gunn has reimagined Superman not as a tale of unstoppable strength but as a heartfelt immigrant story rooted in empathy, humanity, and the universal search for belonging.

Speaking with The Times of London, DC Studios co-head James Gunn offered a fresh perspective on Superman’s story. He explained that Superman represents the journey of an immigrant, arriving from a distant world and making a home among strangers. Gunn stressed that the character’s power is not his most important trait. Instead, he believes Superman’s true legacy is about kindness and compassion, saying, “Basic human kindness is a value and is something we have lost,” a truth he feels modern society must rediscover.

When asked how his Superman film might resonate with today’s politically divided audience, James Gunn responded with honesty and conviction. He acknowledged that some might distort the film’s message of kindness into something divisive, but made it clear he would not let that negativity define the story. Fans have long viewed Superman as an immigrant story. Now, Gunn's projects are sparking fresh debate, this time fueling speculation surrounding Supergirl’s s--uality.

James Gunn Shuns 3 Most Common Superhero Moments - “don’t ever need to see”

What do you think about Supergirl’s s--uality? Let us know in the comments below.