Star Trek: Starfleet Academy has returned with an episode that, remarkably, does not disgrace itself or the viewers. Regular audiences have recognized how each chapter tends to lavish attention on a single cadet, usually the bright-eyed or overly dramatic ones. Caleb has had his dramatics, Darem his brooding, and Kragg his existential crisis. This time, SAM stumbled into the spotlight in episode 5 of Star Trek: Starfleet Academy.

While the last installment dealt with parental expectations, this one lingered in the delightful labyrinth of chosen family and human absurdities.

We finally enter SAM’s world through her own precise, analytical lens. Series Acclamation Mill, known as SAM, introduces herself as a photonic cadet created 2017 days ago on Kasq, the only holographic student at Starfleet Academy, and proudly aware of that statistical anomaly.

SAM explains her mission with admirable clarity. She was sent as a future emissary between Starfleet and her creators, tasked with determining whether organics can be trusted and developing an algorithm to understand their actions, also known as emotions, which she finds aggressively illogical.

One such example is Darem Reymi consuming a banana, despite knowing it was biologically harmful to his species. He accepted a dare, promptly became ill, and vomited glitter, a data point that left SAM impressed, confused, and mildly horrified.

Her creators remain unimpressed by these findings. They criticize her for enrolling in music class rather than focusing on her directive, dismissing her argument that studying emotional expression through art might aid her mission to understand organics.

After this reprimand, SAM investigates a curious parallel. She discovers records of Benjamin Sisko, another emissary who excelled at bridging worlds, yet vanished entirely, a mystery that fascinates SAM more than any algorithm ever could.

“You solve this mystery you can teach the class.” Instructor Aila delivers the ultimatum after persistent interruptions from SAM, reluctantly allowing the photonic cadet into the course despite the semester nearing its end.

Benjamin Sisko emerges from SAM’s research as a Starfleet captain stationed near Bajor during the twenty-fourth century. He also served as the Emissary of the Prophets, god-like beings worshipped by Bajorans, before confronting an enemy at the Fire Gate and vanishing entirely.  SAM reads this history aloud from a thick volume Caleb initially mistakes for a children’s book. She emphasizes, carefully avoiding mention of her creators, that determining whether Benjamin Sisko is alive requires verified evidence, not faith, legend, or comforting assumptions.

Her friends agree with visible reluctance. Kragg commits with alarming enthusiasm, while Ocam delivers a crucial breakthrough by revealing that serious Bajoran devotees congregate regularly inside a Bajoran cultural club which he is a part of. SAM enters the club and immediately learns that Benjamin Sisko is revered less as a man and more as a divine presence. Her attempts to extract concrete answers spiral into disaster when she demands clarity, pulls ears in frustration, and gravely offends nearly everyone present.

The chaos earns her a summons to Chancellor Nahla’s office. Nahla listens carefully, then advises that no emissary can judge others without first understanding themselves, insisting that constant questioning is not a flaw but a necessary discipline. Nahla later visits Kelric’s office and discovers the academy is heating the Pacific Ocean. Kelric explains the decision as preparation for elite guests, including the Chancellor of Elafrati, prompting Nahla to remind him that trust works better than spectacle, and she offers to help him with his diplomatic meeting.

Meanwhile, SAM visits the Benjamin Sisko Museum and absorbs more history than her processors anticipated. She discovers an Orb designed to communicate with the Prophets, attempts to reach Benjamin Sisko directly, and watches the light fade without response. Her focus shifts to Sisko’s family tree, where she learns he had a son. A recorded lecture reveals that the son saw Benjamin Sisko not as an emissary but as a father, a realization that leaves SAM visibly enlightened and emotionally dazzled.

Outside the museum, SAM intersects with Instructor Aila once more. Using a tomato-based analogy, Aila explains that truth cannot be solved through facts alone, reinforcing that understanding requires perspective, patience, and restraint. SAM is abruptly summoned back to her creators, who warn her to abandon distractions or face removal to Kasq as a failure. For the first time, SAM understands that if she does not become a successful emissary here, she will be sent back to Kasq as a failure and far from everyone that she loves and that she only has a week from everything going downhill.

While researching Benjamin Sisko further, SAM follows his past into a bar he once frequented, bringing her friends along. Caleb assists by lowering her behavioral settings, resulting in an unexpectedly exuberant version of SAM who embraces chaos with alarming enthusiasm. Normal SAM struggles with social cues and conversational restraint. Party SAM discards both entirely, embracing volume, affection, and spontaneous declarations, operating less like a diplomat and more like a celebratory malfunction.

The atmosphere grows tense when War College students, including Tarima, appear at the bar. Mutual resentment flares quickly, forcing the bar owner to intervene and remind everyone that communal spaces are not training grounds for academic rivalry. Freed from inhibition, SAM becomes aggressively romantic. She encourages Tarima and Caleb to abandon defensive posturing and acknowledge mutual interest, then applies the same logic to Jay-den Kragg and a War College student who finds Kragg’s blunt honesty genuinely delightful, as seen in episode 2 of Star Trek: Starfleet Academy.

Elsewhere, viewers encounter an unlikely dinner party. Chancellor Nahla, The Doctor, Reno, and Chancellor Kelric dine together as preparation for Kelric’s diplomatic meeting with the Elfarati, a strategy that feels optimistic at best. Nahla coaches Kelric through cultural sensitivity, encourages him to sing, and pranks him once his guard lowers. The moment collapses when Kelric erupts, accusing Nahla of abandoning Starfleet and turning cooperation into personal grievance.

Back at the bar, SAM shifts from matchmaker to protector. When tensions escalate, she delivers a decisive punch to a War College student, igniting a brawl that interrupts Caleb and Tarima’s private conversation and summons emergency reinforcements. The chaos sends everyone to The Doctor for treatment. He orders them back to their dorms, but pauses to express his disappointment in SAM, a reprimand that lands harder than any physical blow.

Before anything else unfolds, Nahla and Kelric resolve their conflict with refreshing maturity. Nahla reminds Kelric that judgment without context is meaningless, and Kelric agrees, confessing his flute performance was catastrophically bad, finally laughing freely through their renewed friendship. SAM, visibly defeated, seeks out Instructor Aila and admits the truth. She realizes the case cannot be solved because proof no longer matters, only the understanding that Benjamin Sisko sacrificed his own desires in service of others as an emissary.

Instructor Aila decides the moment is right to act. She presents SAM with Anselm, the book written by Benjamin Sisko’s son, Jake Sisko, offering not evidence, but perspective, which proves far more dangerous to certainty. In private, SAM opens the book and encounters an illusion of Jake Sisko speaking directly to her. He explains that Benjamin Sisko followed the Prophets, yet always on his own terms, choosing to live fully rather than obediently.

Jake Sisko recounts a defining example. The Prophets warned Benjamin Sisko that marrying Kasidy Yates would bring sorrow, yet he did so anyway, and Jake, Kasidy, and Benjamin shared profound happiness, proving even gods miscalculate human joy. Jake Sisko closes the book with gentle finality and disappears. Instructor Aila arrives to retrieve it, prompting SAM to ask how Aila possessed such an artifact, a question that finally invites long-withheld truth.

Instructor Aila reveals she was entrusted with the book for those ready to understand it properly. SAM connects the remaining clues and realizes Aila is Aila Dax, Benjamin Sisko’s mentor, who admits Sisko would have admired SAM’s relentless curiosity. Strengthened by this revelation, SAM confronts her creators. She explains that understanding organics requires time, that no algorithm can define unpredictability, and that while proof eludes her, trust does not.

SAM declares she will continue as an emissary on her own terms. Like Benjamin Sisko, she will follow guidance without surrendering autonomy, choosing belief, curiosity, and lived experience over obedience dressed as certainty.

‘Star Trek: Starfleet Academy’: Release Date, Cast, Plot, and Everything About the Upcoming Sci-Fi Series

What do you think of SAM's incredible journey inwards in the 5th episode of Star Trek: Starfleet Academy? Let us know in the comments!