Lin-Manuel Miranda has spent years making casting directors look clever, yet he insists Spider-Man: Homecoming would have been the rare exception had he been asked to play Vulture. The architect of the Tony-winning In the Heights has danced through musicals, skipped into Mary Poppins Returns as Jack, and delivered divine charm as Hermes in Percy Jackson and the Olympians. Apparently, sprouting villainous wings was one flourish too many.

Miranda decided that if Marvel wanted him airborne, the invitation could wait for another universe and another character altogether.

During an appearance on Happy Sad Confused, Lin-Manuel Miranda revealed that the Marvel role he famously turned down was none other than Vulture in Spider-Man: Homecoming. Back in 2016, Kevin Feige even walked him through the film's twist-filled plot over the phone. The timing, however, was impossible. Production would begin almost the moment Miranda stepped off the Hamilton stage, and the playwright joked that he preferred staying married to immediately jumping into superhero duty.

"I would have been so miscast," Miranda laughed when Horowitz guessed Martin Starr's part before landing on Vulture, the villain eventually played by Michael Keaton. Starr, of course, ended up portraying Peter Parker's well-meaning teacher, Mr. Roger Harrington. Miranda believed the winged supervillain simply was not written for someone with his particular strengths, no matter how much he adored Marvel's films.

"No, Michael Keaton was perfect," he said on Happy Sad Confused. Miranda never sounded like a man mourning a missed blockbuster paycheck. Instead, he argued Marvel found exactly the actor the role demanded, especially for the unforgettable father-reveal sequence. After years of carrying Hamilton, he admitted that what he truly needed was a vacation, not mechanical wings and a criminal empire.

Kevin Feige Indirectly Confirms Yelena Belova's 'Spider-Man: Brand New Day' Appearance

If Vulture was the role Lin-Manuel Miranda happily left behind, Hamilton was the one he was always meant to soar in.

Lin-Manuel Miranda, whose Moana recently came alive through Polynesian dancers, did not simply star in Hamilton; he built it almost brick by lyrical brick. Inspired by Ron Chernow's biography of Alexander Hamilton, Miranda spent six years transforming an unlikely Founding Father into hip-hop's most improbable leading man. The gamble first surfaced during a 2009 White House performance, where an audience expecting polite history instead witnessed the opening chapter of a cultural revolution.

When Hamilton reached Broadway's Richard Rodgers Theatre in 2015, Miranda stepped into the title role and promptly rewrote the rulebook. Hip-hop shared the stage with Broadway standards, while a deliberately diverse cast reclaimed America's founding story. Miranda remained Alexander Hamilton until July 2016, turning the production into the theatrical event that every ticket buyer desperately wanted to witness.

The awards arrived with the enthusiasm of overeager dinner guests and refused to leave. A Pulitzer Prize, a Grammy, 11 Tony Awards from 16 nominations, and billions in global revenue confirmed that Hamilton was no passing craze. It also made Miranda's Spider-Man confession rather fitting, because history had already found him the only role he was never miscast to play.

‘Moana’: Things Aren't Looking Good for Dwayne Johnson's New Disney Movie

Do you think Lin-Manuel Miranda would have been a good pick for Vulture? Let us know in the comments!