Gwen Stacy, the iconic character from the Spider-Man saga, has dangled between comic pages and film screens like a specter of the web, resonating with loss, love, and promise. The concept has transcended being Peter Parker's love interest to a symbol of what occurs when the most humane emotions meet a superhero's intergalactic peril. With Wednesday's Emma Myers and Stranger Things' Sadie Sink in the race to revive the character on screen, everyone has an opinion to add to the viral buzz, with each having her own lightning-strike potential.

As rumor mills churn wild for Spider-Man: Brand New Day, who is winning the ultimate role of Gwen Stacy? 

Gwen Stacy's superpower lies not on the screen but in pop culture, as the internet is abuzz with potential cast for the role in the upcoming Tom Holland feature, Spider-Man Brand New Day. Recent speculations have indicated that Sadie Sink is highly likely to play Gwen Stacy in the next film. However, the plot outside Brand New Day's script thickens as several X accounts had speculated that Marvel had been eyeing Emma Myers to play the iconic role in an upcoming MCU film. Given their recent streak of hits, it is little surprise that audiences are divided over which actress might embody the role most convincingly, yet the decision remains undecided.

Stealing hearts in Netflix's Wednesday, Myers has become one of the top rumored casting choices for Stacy alongside Sink. Meanwhile, Deadline confirmed that Sink joined Spider-Man: Brand New Day in a major, yet undisclosed, role as fans speculated her character to be either Jean Grey or Gwen Stacy. One theory suggests her role might be Anabelle Adams, the love interest of Spider-Man's clone from Earth-616, per Comic Book Movie. Though there has not been any confirmation on Stacy's role yet, expectations run high for Spidey's next adventure.

Fan Favorite Sadie Sink Reveals a Rare Tactic She Used to 'Protect' Herself From 'Stranger Things' Audience

Whether the new Stacy is a variant or reboot, a new face could ground the romance, embodying the intelligence and kindness of the beloved role, which echoes every swing and web of the superhero. 

Set to hit the theatres in July 2026, Tom Holland returns as Peter Parker with Zendaya as MJ and Jacob Batalon as Ned Leeds by his side in Brand New Day, with the confirmation of Sadie Sink joining the cast. While Gwen Stacy's return to the silver screen in the movie is yet to be confirmed, her legacy continues to weave itself in every web across the Spider-verse. 

Previously, Emma Stone immortalized Stacy in The Amazing Spider-Man and The Amazing Spider-Man 2, while Bryce Dallas Howard breathed life into her in Spider-Man 3, and in animated universes by the likes of Hailee Steinfeld (Spider-Verse). Each added a unique shade to the role, including Howard's poise, Stone's chemistry with Andrew Garfield, and Steinfeld's multiversal depth. With the great rumored responsibility on Sink's shoulders in Brand New Day, there comes great anticipation as viewers want Gwen to be more than a side-love interest but central to Parker's brand new story and not a heartbreaking asterisk.

Sadie Sink Will Have You Forget 'Running Up The Hill' With Her Powerful Vocals in 'O'Dessa'

Who would you like to see play Gwen Stacy next? Tell us in the comments below.