Near Perfect Reviews Did Not Stop Netflix From Remaking a Mystery Thriller That Still Has Everyone Guessing

Published 12/10/2025, 11:11 PM EST

In a twist worthy of Netflix itself, the platform is remaking a murder mystery that once collected near-perfect reviews and rampant theories. The excitement mirrors past Netflix United States fascinations with films like The Invitation and that unsettling tech thriller viewers still argue about.

Netflix United States has long showcased exquisite perplexities, from The Weekend Away, which encourages suspicion with every polite smile, to I Care a Lot, which turns deception into a sport. These selections prove Netflix delights in making viewers feel clever moments before humbling them.

A film adored by almost everyone is uncommon, and Netflix choosing to remake it is rarer still, like boldness politely stepping over predictability.

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

The mystery thriller that Netflix is remaking

Netflix is preparing an American remake of the French mystery thriller Black Box, proving that the service never met a suspenseful enigma it did not wish to recycle. The project arrives only four years after the original baffled audiences with elegant precision.

Director Tim Fehlbaum, known for the dystopian feature September 5, will guide the adaptation. His involvement suggests Netflix hopes to blend European tension with American urgency, a combination that often results in viewers Googling explanations five minutes into the film.

The production lineup, as per Deadline, includes Andrew Mittman of Elvis fame, along with Wassim Beji, Thibault Gast, and Matthias Weber, who shepherded the original. Their reunion gives the remake an air of familial supervision, like proud relatives ensuring no one smudges the legacy.

The initial film earned glowing descriptions from critics who enjoy their conspiracies refined. Netflix now attempts its own interpretation, demonstrating that even a well-regarded thriller may be invited back to the stage when the platform desires one more bow.

Fact Check: Is DC Reviving Henry Cavill’s Superman for a Black Adam Movie?

Black Box presents such a refined collection of strengths that its popularity reads less like hype and more like a professional obligation.

The acclaimed French thriller Netflix has set its sight on

The French thriller Black Box became a major success in France, earning a 94 percent Rotten Tomatoes score and a 7.2 IMDb rating. Audiences responded to its meticulous aviation investigation, which portrayed black box decoding with the precision usually reserved for national archives.

Pierre Niney anchored the film with an intense performance as Mathieu Vasseur, a black box analyst whose obsession turns every audio fragment into a potential revelation. His portrayal carried the film so effectively that viewers followed his paranoia as if it were a guided tour.

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

The movie’s acclaimed sound design replicated cockpit audio with unsettling accuracy, earning a César Award nomination. Each recording became a narrative weapon, allowing the film to build tension not with explosions but with static, alarms, and professionally suppressed panic.

Netflix likely sees the film’s blend of technical authenticity, conspiracy-driven storytelling, and modern relevance, including themes reminiscent of the Boeing 737 Max controversy, as ideal for an American audience. A remake lets the platform repackage a proven hit with its preferred dramatic scope.

Golden Globe Nominations 2025: Every Netflix Nominee Shaping the Film and TV Race

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

What are your views on Netflix's decision to remake Black Box? Let us know in the comments!

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :

ADVERTISEMENT

Iffat Siddiqui

727 articles

Iffat is an Entertainment Journalist at Netflix Junkie. A word wizard, she had the sorting hat smoke at the seams owing to her excellence in everything Hollywood and cinema until it finally declared that she belonged to the Royals, specifically Meghan Markle. Boasting over 300 articles (and counting), each one tastefully infused with the right mix of facts, wit, opinion, and essentially everything to make a perfect pop culture piece, she is the epitome of a trustworthy entertainment journalist.

Edited By: Itti Mahajan

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

EDITORS' PICK