NBC has begun shaping its 2026–27 slate with its first wave of cancellations, and the decisions are already making headlines. The network has officially pulled the plug on Brilliant Minds, the sophomore medical drama led by Zachary Quinto, and Stumble, the freshman cheerleading comedy starring Jenn Lyon. The move marks the beginning of what could be a broader shake-up across the network’s scripted lineup. It also reflects NBC’s increasing focus on performance metrics and audience retention.

NBC’s early cuts signal a strategic reset, as the network reassesses which series align best with its long-term programming vision. With more renewal and cancellation decisions still pending, industry watchers are closely tracking what comes next. The ripple effects of these choices could shape the network’s identity for the upcoming season.

 Despite holding a prime Monday slot behind The Voice, Brilliant Minds struggled with ratings and saw steep year-over-year declines, as reported by Deadline. NBC had already signaled trouble earlier this year when it pulled the show from its schedule; the remaining episodes are now set to roll out later in May.

Meanwhile, Stumble faced a different challenge. Though the mockumentary-style comedy earned strong critical and audience scores, it failed to find a broad enough viewership. Scheduling shifts and creative backing were not enough to secure a renewal, ultimately sealing its fate after just one season.

With two shows gone, attention now shifts to the bubble titles, including The Hunting Party and the long-running Law & Order. While The Hunting Party has shown some promise, particularly with streaming traction, its linear ratings remain modest. Law & Order, on the other hand, continues to be a steady performer but still lags behind other franchise hits, leaving its future unexpectedly uncertain as NBC weighs its next move.

‘Below Deck’ Alum Emile Kotze Alleges Producers Engineered Romance for Ratings in Lawsuit Against NBCUniversal

As NBC makes tough programming decisions, canceled shows like La Brea are proving their story may not end with a network exit.

La Brea made its way to Netflix on May 1, 2026, where all three seasons of the previously canceled NBC sci-fi drama are now available to stream. Originally airing from 2021 to 2024, the series carved out a niche with its mix of disaster storytelling and prehistoric survival, standing out within the crowded sci-fi space. Developed by David Appelbaum, the plot kicks off with a massive sinkhole at Los Angeles’ La Brea Tar Pits, sending a group of strangers into a mysterious world set in 10,000 B.C., where survival becomes their only priority.

Led by Eoin Macken, Natalie Zea, and Zyra Gorecki, the show spans 30 episodes, making it a relatively quick watch for streaming audiences. Its arrival on Netflix has reignited conversations around its earlier cancellation, especially as more viewers discover it for the first time. With streaming platforms often reshaping a show’s legacy, La Brea now has the opportunity to reach a wider audience, highlighting how network decisions don’t always mark the end of a series’ journey.

NBC’s early decisions signal a clear shift in priorities as it refines its programming strategy for the coming season. While Brilliant Minds and Stumble have reached the end of their run, the uncertainty surrounding Law & Order and The Hunting Party keeps fans guessing. 

‘The Hunting Party’ Starring Melissa Roxburgh Lands on Netflix Amid Season 2 Run on NBC

Do you think NBC made the right call canceling Brilliant Minds and Stumble, or should they have been given another season? Let us know in the comments!