Jeffrey Dean Morgan almost became Batman, and the idea came directly from director Zack Snyder himself. Long before Morgan settled into playing Thomas Wayne in Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice, there was a bigger vision brewing behind the scenes. The two had crossed paths on Watchmen, and their bond apparently sparked conversations far beyond a single scene. What started as a passing comment eventually grew into something Morgan still thinks about today.

While fans only saw a brief cameo on screen, the real story behind it runs far deeper than anyone realized.

Jeffrey Dean Morgan confirmed that Zack Snyder once envisioned him taking on the role of Batman, not just Bruce Wayne's father. During a conversation on the Happy Sad Confused podcast, Morgan recalled the moment Snyder first floated the idea during their Watchmen press tour.

"He was like, 'I would love to see you play Batman,'" he said.

But Morgan later clarified, "I think at one point he like had looked over and just said Flashpoint and I was like, 'Oh God d*** it'"

That single word carried enormous weight, since Flashpoint remains tied to alternate timelines and older versions of iconic heroes within DC lore. Morgan admitted the moment left him stunned, joking that he nearly had a heart attack hearing Snyder tease something so massive. Despite the excitement, Warner Bros never moved forward with those plans, and Morgan's Batman ambitions stayed confined to conversations. Morgan also shared his admiration for Snyder's deep understanding of DC iconography during the Happy Sad Confused podcast.

The Survival Thriller That Took Netflix by Surprise Is Finally Getting a Sequel

While one almost-role stayed buried in speculation, another failed audition years earlier nearly buried his entire acting career.

Jeffrey Dean Morgan revealed that a miserable Star Trek appearance once pushed him close to abandoning acting altogether. The heavily prosthetic alien role trapped him in makeup for fourteen hours a day, leaving him claustrophobic and unable to eat properly. He described the experience as something he still dreams about negatively, calling it one of the toughest stretches of his early career. That frustration nearly convinced him to walk away from the industry for good.

Instead, Morgan pushed through years of odd jobs, poster art, and constant auditions before finally landing Grey's Anatomy and Supernatural around the same period. His manager had dropped him right before those roles arrived, calling him washed up in the business. Looking back, Morgan seems to find humor in how close he came to missing both Grey's Anatomy and a potential Batman cape entirely. Sometimes the biggest breaks arrive right after the darkest doubts.

'The Walking Dead: Dead City' Season 3: Release Date, Cast, Plot, and All About Negan and Maggie’s New Expeditions

What are your thoughts on Zack Snyder's unrealized Batman plan for Jeffrey Dean Morgan? Let us know in the comments.