Matthew Lillard has teased that his mysterious character in James Gunn’s Man of Tomorrow is an original creation, rather than someone lifted directly from DC Comics. The actor’s description of the casting as “a very James Gunn moment” offers a tantalizing clue about the filmmaker’s approach to expanding the DC Universe. For fans busy connecting comic-book dots, this might be a case where the answer is not hiding in the panels.

Gunn has never treated superhero storytelling as a simple exercise in checking names off a roster. His DCU thrives on unexpected personalities, unconventional supporting players, and characters who can make even the most familiar comic-book mythology feel unpredictable. Lillard’s latest comments suggest that Man of Tomorrow could have another such wildcard waiting in the wings.

During an exclusive interview with The Direct while promoting Prime Video’s Carrie, Matthew Lillard was asked whether his mystery character in Man of Tomorrow would be familiar to comic-book readers or specifically created for the upcoming sequel. His answer was brief, but it offered a meaningful hint about where audiences should direct their speculation.

“It’s a very James Gunn moment,” Lillard explained.

 “So, I wouldn’t worry too much about finding him in the comics,” Lillard said. 

The comment suggests that the character may have been developed specifically for the film, although it does not conclusively establish that Lillard is playing an entirely new figure with no comic-book connections.

The casting also reunites Lillard with Gunn, who wrote the live-action Scooby-Doo movies in which the actor played Shaggy Rogers. Gunn previously dismissed speculation that Lillard would portray Barry Allen, the DC Universe’s familiar speedster. That clarification already ruled out one popular theory, and this latest tease gives fans another reason to reconsider their detective work.

X Accuses James Gunn of “Hijacking” ‘Clayface’ From Matt Reeves, Fans Divided

Still, an original character does not necessarily mean a minor one. Gunn has repeatedly demonstrated an interest in making unexpected figures matter to his larger stories, giving even unconventional additions room to develop beyond their first appearance.

The bigger mystery is whether Matthew Lillard’s character will remain on the sidelines of Metropolis or become a recurring presence in James Gunn’s expanding superhero saga. One online rumor from Atlanta DC Fans claims that the actor will play a character with a biracial family who shares scenes with Daily Planet figures Jimmy Olsen, Cat Grant, and Perry White. This report remains unconfirmed, so the details should be treated as speculation rather than established casting information.

If the rumor proves accurate, Lillard could be playing a Daily Planet-adjacent character whose influence comes from his connections to Clark Kent’s journalistic world rather than superhuman abilities. Such a role would fit Gunn’s interest in grounding extraordinary stories in recognizable human relationships. It could also allow Lillard to bring his energetic screen presence to a corner of the DCU that does not necessarily involve a cape, a mask, or a supervillain monologue.

For now, Lillard’s role in Man of Tomorrow remains under wraps, but his comments point toward a character designed to serve Gunn’s particular vision of the DCU. Whether the mystery figure becomes a familiar face in Metropolis or develops into a larger piece of the franchise, there is plenty of room for surprises.

James Gunn Gushes About Tom Rhys’ ‘Clayface’, Lauds the Emotional Weight in Hit DC Horror

What do you think Matthew Lillard is playing in Man of Tomorrow? Share your theories in the comments.