On Pandora, belonging is written into the body. You breathe the air, ride the creatures, plug your queue into the world, then, you are accepted. Spider does none of these things. Yet from the moment The Way of Water introduced Miles “Spider” Socorro, the human boy running barefoot through the jungle, he felt inseparable from the Sully story. He laughs with the children, speaks Na’vi fluently, and knows the rhythms of the forest.

But he also removes his mask to remind us he does not truly belong. That contradiction has made Spider one of Avatar’s most polarizing figures, both within the narrative and among audiences, prompting a persistent question ahead of Avatar: Fire and Ash - was James Cameron planning to remove him?

As the franchise moves toward darker themes and moral fracture, Spider’s fate is no longer an uncertain question. It may define the future shape of the Avatar saga itself.

Despite ongoing speculation, Spider was never removed from Avatar: Fire and Ash. In fact, director James Cameron has confirmed that the opposite happened — that is, the Avatar sequels stopped working when he tried to write the character out.

Speaking to Entertainment Weekly, Cameron revealed that during the development of The Way of Water, Fire and Ash, and even the two future sequels, he seriously considered eliminating Spider. Why? Simply due to the sheer logistical difficulty of filming a live-action human child alongside performance-capture Na’vi characters. 

“We knew it was gonna be hard to shoot an actor in live action and surround that character with all these people that are twice his size,” Cameron explained to Entertainment Weekly, acknowledging the technical and scale challenges involved.

Every attempt to remove Spider, however, exposed a deeper narrative problem. Without Spider acting as the connective tissue between Jake Sully and his enemy-turned-mirror, Quaritch, the conflict lost its complexity. This, along with Cameron's doubling doubts over the third instalment, ensured Spider remained in the movie.

‘Avatar’ 3 Reviews: James Cameron’s Doubts Are a Looming Reality as ‘Fire and Ash’ Leaves Everyone Waiting for More

With Spider firmly cemented in the story, the next question becomes how will his unique abilities shape the new threats. 

Avatar: Fire and Ash is releasing this Friday and picks up immediately after the grief-stricken events of The Way of Water. The Sully family is still mourning the loss of Neteyam, their eldest son, and the emotional strain is evident. Jake and Neytiri are struggling to process their grief in ways that create tension within the family. 

On the battlefield, the danger escalates as Colonel Quaritch and the RDA continue their relentless assault. It is now complicated by the arrival of the Ash People, a volcanic Na’vi clan led by the formidable Varang. 

Amidst this backdrop, Spider’s role becomes increasingly crucial as he undergoes significant transformation. He gains the ability to breathe Pandora’s normally toxic air and even grows his own “queue,” connecting with creatures and the environment in ways previously unique to the Na’vi.

These abilities make him a strategic asset to the RDA, yet his importance extends beyond utility. He embodies the moral and human dimension of the story. Spider’s outsider identity is now inseparable from Pandora itself. So integral that even James Cameron has admitted the story collapses without him.

‘Avatar: Fire and Ash’ Screenings Will Feature 4 ‘Avengers: Doomsday Trailers’ - Here’s When Each One Drops

Will you be catching Avatar: Fire and Ash in theaters this weekend, or waiting it out? Let us know in the comments below.