There was a time when The CW’s DC universe felt like comic-book Christmas every week. Arrow had grit, Legends of Tomorrow had glorious nonsense, and Supergirl brought Kryptonian sunshine, but The Flash was the bright red crown jewel.

Grant Gustin’s Barry Allen had heart, Tom Cavanagh’s Reverse-Flash had menace, and S.T.A.R. Labs felt like the clubhouse every DC geek wanted to sneak into after school. Season 1 remains a superhero-TV comfort blanket for many fans. Twelve years after the 2014 premiere, however, the series carries a strangely bruised legacy.

So how did “Run, Barry, run” eventually become “Please, Barry, just end this”?

Early The Flash worked because Barry Allen's powers never replaced his problems. Reverse-Flash murdered his mother, Zoom broke him physically and emotionally, and the show treated super-speed like a gift wrapped around trauma. Even its most ridiculous comic-book ingredients, including telepathic gorillas and time travel, had enough sincerity underneath to make the madness sing.

Then the treadmill became visible. Speedster villains returned repeatedly. Timelines were broken, repaired, rewritten, and broken again. Characters kept discovering powers, secret identities, alternate selves, future children, evil doubles, cosmic upgrades, and increasingly elaborate reasons to gather around a S.T.A.R. Labs monitor while somebody shouted scientific gibberish.

By Season 9, Den of Geek was openly criticizing the abundance of Cecile, the awkward Chester-Allegra romance, and the strange decision to replace Caitlin with Khione during the final stretch. Barry himself also began sharing more narrative oxygen with an ever-expanding Team Flash.

Later seasons also struggled to balance Chester, Allegra, Cecile, Khione, Chillblaine, and assorted Rogues, sometimes leaving established characters with thin material while side plots swallowed precious final-season episodes. The fastest man alive had somehow become trapped inside television’s busiest group chat.

'The Flash' Movie That Never Was: Oscar-Winning Duo Behind Spider-Verse Movies Reveal Their "Elaborate" Lost Script

And once the supporting cast became crowded, the finale found an even bigger way to irritate longtime fans.

A final season should feel like a victory lap. The Flash occasionally delivered that sensation, particularly when Oliver Queen returned and when the show revisited Barry’s history with Eobard Thawne. Yet the actual finale assembled Reverse-Flash, Zoom, Savitar and Godspeed into a supervillain reunion, then dispatched several of them with astonishing speed.

TVLine described the matchups themselves as almost random. Cecile handled Godspeed, Allegra knocked out Reverse-Flash, and Nora survived another encounter with Savitar before defeating him. Villains who had once consumed entire seasons suddenly felt like arcade enemies somebody had accidentally set to beginner difficulty.

That frustration explains much of the lingering hostility. Fans remember how genuinely great the show could be. Grant Gustin remained an enormously sincere Barry, and the first two seasons proved that colorful DC mythology could thrive on television without apologizing for itself. The disappointment comes from watching that lightning slowly diffuse across nine increasingly crowded years.

Curiously, Gorilla Grodd may provide the next breadcrumb toward the Flash corner of James Gunn’s DCU. HBO Max is developing DC Crime, a mock true-crime series hosted by Skyler Gisondo’s Jimmy Olsen, with its first season centered on Grodd, one of Barry Allen’s most famous enemies.

No DCU Flash has been announced, but introducing his telepathic ape nemesis certainly leaves an interesting red-and-gold-shaped hole in the room. Perhaps the next Barry Allen will inherit the one lesson his CW predecessor learned the hard way: even super-speed cannot outrun nine seasons of baggage.

Fact Check: Has Grant Gustin Really Been Cast as The Flash in James Gunn’s DCU?

What do you think caused The Flash to lose so much goodwill? Was it the repetitive villains, crowded Team Flash stories, or the finale? Let us know in the comments.