Erin Moriarty walks into The Boys like a moral compass accidentally dropped into a room full of chaos, and somehow makes it compelling. As Annie January, also known as Starlight, Moriarty anchors the narrative with a clarity that directly challenges Homelander’s sociopathy. Whether exposing corruption or navigating fame, she delivers a performance that proves optimism can be powerful without being naive.

Beyond fascination with Starlight’s arc, fans remain equally invested in whether Erin Moriarty has been romantically involved with anyone recently.

Erin Moriarty has not publicly confirmed any romantic relationship, a detail that only seems to energize speculation further. The absence of confirmation has created a vacuum that fans enthusiastically fill with relationship rumors of their own. And at the center of Erin Moriarty's relationship rumors is none other than her The Boys cast members, Anthony Starr and Jack Quaid.

The most persistent rumor pairs Erin Moriarty with Antony Starr, whom Moriarty considers her off-screen best friend. While some see nothing beyond close co-stars, their regular sightings in casual settings, lunches in Beverly Hills, or dog-walking routines have others reading between the lines that may not exist. Neither has confirmed nor denied the speculation that The Boys co-stars are dating secretly, leaving the rumor unverified.

On the other hand, Jack Quaid presents a case of fiction being mistaken for biography. As Annie January and Hughie, the pair play romance with convincing tenderness, so convincing that fans wanted them to date in real life. However, the rumor mill stopped mainly because of Jack Quaid's ongoing relationship with Claudia Doumit since 2022. As for Moriarty and Quaid, the two remain good friends off-screen, while leaving people's curiosity about Moriarty's love life blissfully unanswered.

'The Boys' Finale Won’t Get a Movie-Length Finale, Eric Kripke Reveals Why

Erin Moriarty appears almost as strategically elusive as Professor Moriarty when it comes to relationships, with only one rumored past link, and even that remains frustratingly unconfirmed.

It is widely believed that Erin Moriarty and Jacob Artist shared more than just screen time during After the Dark, also known as The Philosophers. Filmed in Jakarta, their on-set dynamic as classmates translated into an off-screen closeness that did not go unnoticed. The originators of this rumor believe that the young stars first started dating while filming for the show abroad.

Fueling the narrative were Moriarty’s social media posts, particularly a candid May 2013 photograph with a caption saying that she missed her partner in crime. Fans were quick to interpret the phrasing as more than playful familiarity. Their frequent appearances together during and after production further strengthened assumptions. However, neither Moriarty nor Artist chose to clarify the nature of their relationship publicly.

The connection appeared to dissolve by late 2014, just as both careers gathered speed in different directions. Artist remained occupied with Glee, while Moriarty edged toward more prominent visibility with Jessica Jones. They seem to have preserved a polite professional rapport since. As for speculation, whether romantic or plastic surgeries, Moriarty continues to navigate it all with her characteristic discretion.

'Gen V' Season 3 Receives A Disappointing Update As 'The Boys' Final Season Gears Up For Release

What do you think of Erin Moriarty's dating life? Let us know in the comments!