‘Eager to Play a Character’— Billy Evans Breaks Silence on Amanda Seyfried’s Role in ‘You Can See Everything’

Published 11/16/2026, 9:42 AM CST
Amanda Seyfried at the photocall for the feature film Seven Veils at the Berlinale 2024 74 Berlin International Film Festival at the Hotel Grand Hyatt Berlin, 22 02 2024 Foto:xN.xKubelkax xFuturexImagex veils_4277

Billy Evans, has finally shared his thoughts on Amanda Seyfried’s portrayal of Elizabeth Holmes in You Can See Everything, and he does not appear particularly impressed. The documentary may promise an unusually intimate look at the former Theranos founder, but its decision to bring an Emmy-winning actress into the picture introduces another layer to an already complicated portrait.

For Evans, who shared a home with Holmes during filming, the distinction between the woman and the performance seems rather important. And the person who once brought Holmes to life on television has now become part of the documentary’s own uncomfortable reality.

Billy Evans weighs in on Amanda Seyfried’s portrayal of Elizabeth Holmes

In his first televised interview with CBS News’ Matt Gutman, Haemanthus CEO and longtime partner of the infamous Elizabeth Holmes, Billy Evans, was asked about Amanda Seyfried’s involvement in the documentary and her portrayal of Holmes. When Gutman pressed him on whether he thought Seyfried had played Holmes well, Evans said that he was “glad Nathan was there to help her.” Otherwise, his response was pointed.

“I’m really glad that they included her because it shows what a difference there is between the real thing and how eager she was to play a character,” he said.  

Caption: Elizabeth Holmes in You Can See EverythingCredit: A24

Evans' remarks made on CBS arrive after Seyfried described her own uneasy experience filming with Evans. In an interview with The Rolling Stone, she said her opinion of him “only got worse” after their meeting, particularly following a tense dinner conversation in which he criticized her acting, while she raised questions about how he treated Holmes, his longtime partner and the mother of his children. 

‘You Can See Everything’ Eyes a Rare $100M Milestone, a Feat Few Documentaries Reach

The exchange is especially striking because Seyfried was not initially brought into the project as another subject of its investigation.

You Can See Everything turned a private household into a documentary

Directed by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, You Can See Everything began with the filmmakers spending 34 days inside the home Elizabeth Holmes shared with Billy Evans before she reported to prison in 2023. The project eventually expanded into a three-year undertaking, with Amanda Seyfried joining after the directors reconsidered how to approach the footage. Her Emmy-winning performance as Holmes in Hulu’s The Dropout made her an unusual addition, blurring the boundaries between documentary observation and dramatic reconstruction.

Mamma Mia! Here We Go Again - World premiere Amanda Seyfried, Thomas Sadoski, Mamma Mia! Here We Go Again - World premiere, Eventim Apollo, Hammersmith, London, UK, 16 July 2018, Photo by Richard Goldschmidt London London UK

The film follows Holmes and Evans through the final weeks before her incarceration, examining their domestic life while the consequences of the Theranos fraud conviction remain close at hand. A24 released it theatrically on October 16, with Fielder and Oppenheim directing and producing alongside Tatiana Bears, Maggie Ambrose and Jack Davis. Its reception has been striking, earning rave reviews and substantial audience attention, while the involvement of Seyfried has added an unexpected, meta-narrative to the story. 

"Never Blinked Once"- John Oliver Roasts Elizabeth Holmes and Billy Evans Over 'You Can See Everything'

What did you think of Amanda Seyfried's performance? Let us know in the comments. 

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :

Adiba Nizami

1187 articles

Adiba Nizami is a journalist at Netflix Junkie. Covering the Hollywood beat with a voice both sharp and stylish, she blends factual precision with a flair for wit. Her pieces often dissect celebrity narratives—both on-screen and off—through parasocial nuance and cultural relevance.

Edited By: Hriddhi Maitra

EDITORS' PICK