'Conjuring' Prequel: 5 Horrifically Perfect Plot Ideas You Wish Were Made Into a Reality

The Conjuring Universe has dragged audiences through darkened hallways, cursed artifacts, and the malevolent whispers of entities that defy explanation, each installment more chilling than the last. From the Perron family’s haunted Rhode Island farmhouse to the demon-possessed courtroom of Arne Cheyenne Johnson, and the cursed relics that stir in the shadows of the Warrens’ artifact room, terror seeps from every corner, promising that no soul is safe. The latest chapter, The Conjuring: Last Rites, has shattered box office records, yet the darkness is far from over, and now, a new prequel is in consideration, as per Puck News.
Imagine nightmares so vivid they refuse to fade, five bone-chilling storylines that could be unleashed into a terrifying prequel reality.
Brookfield’s dark secrets: The case that sparked a legend
ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues below this ad
In the 1950s, long before their fame, a young Ed and Lorraine Warren face their first major case: a farmhouse tormented by violent, unpredictable poltergeist activity. The haunting is not merely demonic but entwined with a tragic family secret that feeds on buried guilt. Shadows twist, objects hurl themselves, and whispers echo through empty halls, testing the Warrens’ inexperience and straining their marriage.

Amid the terror, cursed objects emerge, hinting at future horrors and forging the couple’s legendary reputation in a crucible of fear, doubt, and despair.
Secrets of the Perron House: Spirits that refused to rest
In the 1800s, long before the Perron family ever set foot in Rhode Island, Bathsheba lived and thrived, sowing darkness across the land that would become the cursed Perron house. This chilling tale traces her descent into malevolence, revealing the origins of the infamous curse and the horrors that would echo centuries later.

By exploring the story from her perspective, the film delivers gothic period terror, connecting to the first Conjuring movie while showing how Bathsheba’s spirit transformed into the relentless, vengeful force feared by all.
These first two plotlines may feel like stepping into pure nightmare fuel, but the terror does not end there, three more stories wait in the shadows, each as chilling as The Conjuring itself.
The Conjuring in Salem: Spirits born from history
During the Salem Witch Trials, fear and hysteria gripped the town, but beneath the chaos lurked a real demonic presence, feeding on paranoia and innocence. A young Puritan woman, wrongly accused, discovers that a true demon manipulates the trials to grow its dark power.
Candlelit streets and shadowed chambers heighten the terror, blending historical fact with supernatural dread. This story is thematically rich, visually haunting, and threads connections to modern haunted artifacts and cursed bloodlines, linking Salem’s horrors to the present in chilling, unforgettable ways.
From town to town: The Devil’s Road leaves no soul unscathed
In the 1960s, a Vatican-sanctioned team journeys across Europe, investigating a series of brutal supernatural murders that reveal a hidden, worldwide network of demonic cultists. Shadows of evil stretch from remote villages to grand cathedrals, testing the investigators’ courage and faith.

This story expands the horror beyond America, introduces compelling new characters with potential for future tales, and hints at the demonic forces the Warrens will confront, weaving a chilling tapestry of global terror without ever invoking Valak directly.
The Warren Museum: secrets behind the haunted artifacts
In the 1920s, a young priest stumbles upon a series of cursed items, each more malevolent than the last, destined for the Warren Museum. Three interconnected tales unfold: a mirror that traps wandering souls, a wedding dress driving brides to murder, and a children’s toy tied to a dark cult.
ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues below this ad

As the priest gathers the artifacts, he realizes a hidden evil has been guiding him, orchestrating their collection. Fans also wonder if The Conjuring: Last Rites will soon appear on Netflix, and now a chilling prequel in the works promises even deeper horrors.
ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues below this ad
Are you excited to watch The Conjuring prequel? Let us know in the comments below
ADVERTISEMENT
Edited By: Hriddhi Maitra
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT




