Can a Horror Film Finally Win Best Picture? Why ‘Sinners’ Could Break the Academy’s Genre Barrier

Gold statues have long gravitated toward restraint rather than rupture. Lavish period dramas, war epics, and intimate character studies traditionally command the loudest applause beneath industry chandeliers. Yet beyond velvet curtains, another cinematic language has flourished, one shaped by dread, folklore, and psychological unease.
As the 98th race gathers momentum, conversation drifts toward whether fear itself may finally ascend the grandest stage through Sinners, reframing how prestige is defined.
Like all things on Earth, the Academy Awards is walking a path of transience, and in its almost-century old existence, might finally cross the thresholds of genre.
ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues below this ad
The Oscars' new favorite
The Academy Awards have historically approached horror with caution. Landmark entries such as The Exorcist, Carrie, The Sixth Sense, and more did secure nominations, yet never actually attained victory. The genre has often been categorized as sensational rather than sophisticated, its craft overshadowed by assumptions of spectacle over substance.
Even with sporadic recognition, Best Picture remained firmly aligned with dramatic traditionalism rather than atmospheric terror. Shifts, however, appear underway as the 98th ceremony approaches its March 2026 unveiling. Sinners has emerged as a formidable contender, amassing widespread nominations, including Best Picture. Industry observers interpret this surge as evidence of evolving voter sensibilities.
The film’s blend of historical weight and supernatural menace positions it beyond conventional horror frameworks, suggesting that thematic gravity may finally override long-held institutional hesitation.
Directed by Ryan Coogler, the narrative follows twin brothers fleeing moral wreckage in Chicago, only to confront vampiric terror within the Mississippi Delta. The horror is tethered to Jim Crow-era trauma, interweaving social history with familial reckoning. Michael B. Jordan leads in dual roles, supported by Hailee Steinfeld and Delroy Lindo.
While Sinners are set to make history this award season, there is more than one record maker gracing the 98th Academy Awards, too.
The 2026 Oscars' record makers
The 98th Academy Awards nominations carried historic weight. Announced on January 22, 2026, the slate cemented records. Sinners secured sixteen nominations, surpassing the likes of All About Eve, Titanic, and La La Land. Milestones extended to nominees, with Timothée Chalamet, 30, becoming the youngest to belt three acting nominations in one go. Emma Stone, 37, who now holds 7 nominations, becoming the youngest woman to earn seven Oscar nominations.
ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues below this ad
Whether Sinners ultimately claims the industry’s highest honor remains uncertain, yet its presence alone recalibrates expectations. The Academy now confronts a symbolic crossroads between preservation and progress. A victory for Ryan Coogler would validate horror as both a cultural mirror and an artistic force.
As ballots close and anticipation intensifies, the 98th ceremony stands poised to determine whether fear itself can finally be crowned with gold.
ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues below this ad
Do you think Sinner will take the Best Picture Award this year? Let us know in the comments.
ADVERTISEMENT
Edited By: Hriddhi Maitra
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT



