Amy Poehler Crowns Jimmy Fallon the Best Paul McCartney Impersonator With Approval From The Beatles Singer Himself

Published 11/17/2026, 2:28 AM EST
Jimmy Fallon USA , during the 2026 Formula One Miami Grand Prix, 4th round of the 2026 Formula 1 World Championship at Miami International Autodrome on May 01, 2026 in Miami, United States Photo by Philippe Nanchino Eurasia Sport Images Miami Miami International Autodrome United States of America Copyright: x x2026xEurasiaxSportxImagesx jp-en-EuSpIm-MPS_PPN_GP_F1_USA_01May2026_US030

Over the course of his career, Jimmy Fallon has worn plenty of hats, from late-night host and Oscars emcee to prankster-in-chief and sketch performer. Each one has earned him its share of praise from guests, peers, and fans. Yet the latest compliment to land on his desk may be the most unusual of the lot.

Hand-delivered by Amy Poehler and containing an approval stamp for Paul McCartney himself, just like that, Fallon was crowned the best Paul McCartney impersonator of all time.

Jimmy Fallon wins Best Paul McCartney impersonator

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

The race to become the next James Bond played out for years, with one name after another tipped for the tuxedo, until Robert Pattinson walked away with the martini. A similarly high-stakes contest has now reached its own winner, though this one involves a different British icon and a very different kind of impression.

Amy Poehler gave the title of best Paul McCartney impersonator to Jimmy Fallon, and the name came straight from the Beatles legend himself.

Caption: Jimmy Fallon's 'On Brand' show cancelledCredits: Imago

Poehler appeared on The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon amidst her TV comeback with Dig where she reflected on the absolute joy she felt interviewing McCartney. To add the cherry on top, McCartney was the one iconic celebrity that her parents also could not stop fangirling over.

Amy Poehler Reveals Which Hollywood A-Lister She Served Before Making It Big

If landing a McCartney interview had Poehler’s parents beaming, Dig could well be the encore that makes them prouder still.

What is Dig about?

Set against the sun-baked ruins of a Greek archaeological site, Dig follows four women who are each standing at a turning point in their lives. Their quiet excavation takes a sharp turn when an unexpected discovery uncovers a long-buried secret, pulling the group into a high-stakes international conspiracy. Based on Kate Myers’ book Excavations, the Peacock comedy reunites Amy Poehler with Parks and Recreation creator Mike Schur, who co-created the series with her and co-wrote the pilot.

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

NEW YORK, NY - MAY 8: Tina Fey, Maya Rudolph, Amy Poehler, Paula Pell, Rachel Dratch, Ana Gasteyer and Emily Spivey at The World Premiere of Amy Poehler?s Wine Country at The Paris Theater on May 8, 2019 in New York City. Copyright: xDiegoxCorredor MediaPunchx

Hugh Laurie, Geraldine Viswanathan, Antonia Thomas and Fina Strazza round out the cast, with Poehler leading as Elise. This marks Poehler's first leading return to scripted television since Parks and Recreation wrapped in 2015, more than a decade away from the format. With Dig set to land on November 23, Poehler’s comeback may well earn a crown of its own, but Fallon already has his, thanks to the one judge who matters most: Paul McCartney himself.

‘Ray Gunn’ on Netflix Release Date, Voice Cast, Plot, and Everything to Know About Brad Bird’s Animated Movie

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

What do you think about Amy Poehler's crowning Jimmy Fallon the best Paul McCartney impersonator? Let us know in the comments.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :

ADVERTISEMENT

Aliza Siddiqui

2067 articles

Aliza Siddiqui is an Entertainment Journalist and Primary Editor at Netflix Junkie. With over a thousand articles previously published at Otakukart, she brings a seasoned voice to pop culture storytelling—infused with her signature wit and editorial finesse. Her passion for cinema sparked with Anne Hathaway’s Princess Diaries and deepened through films like Don't Look Up and The Dictator, which shaped her appreciation for satire and subtext.

Edited By: Itti Mahajan

ADVERTISEMENT

EDITORS' PICK