Heidi Klum's Halloween looks are always so iconic that now, every Halloween is a "Happy Heidi Klum Day." This year, her bloody, severed hand, tiptoeing on two fingers, was the highlight of the night, which has further cemented her place as the Queen of Halloween.

However, while her look was the talk of the town as always, it seems that her hand has contributed to apparent major leaks for the upcoming, highly anticipated The Batman: Part II.

It is funny how both Dune: Part One and The Batman released in the same year 2022, and yet, Dune is about to complete its trilogy, while fans howl for even a leak from the sequel of Gotham's protector. And what is even funnier is that how it took a single prosthetic severed hand to serve fans with not one but four alleged leaks—each seemingly taking a swipe at Batman’s famous “no-kill” rule.

Internet detectives might not be able to solve every mystery but they have discovered from the images of Heidi Klum’s Halloween makeup team some alleged leaks about The Batman: Part II. First, a heavily scarred facial cast resembling Brian Tyree Henry has fueled speculation that he could be playing Harvey Dent, aka Two-Face.

Then there’s a container labeled “Zsasz,” as seen in the images, seemingly lending weight to rumors that Sebastian Stan is portraying the serial killer Victor Zsasz rather than Dent. A third clue comes in the form of an “Owl 3” label, which fans believe could hint at the Court of Owls. Finally, the casting of an older man has sparked theories about Sebastian Koch’s role. Gotham’s secrets may have been caught red-handed—but none of these clues have been officially confirmed.

“I Thought I Knew Something“ - Sebastian Stan Gets a Reality Check After Crossing From Marvel to ‘The Batman Part II’

The alleged clues have already sent fans into detective mode, but there’s a bigger question lurking beneath the prosthetics-room mystery: where does Matt Reeves’ next trip to Gotham stand at? 

While the alleged leaks have given fans plenty to chew on, The Batman: Part II has been keeping its actual story firmly under wraps. Robert Pattinson is returning as the Caped Crusader, with Matt Reeves co-writing the screenplay alongside Mattson Tomlin and directing the sequel. The cast includes Scarlett Johansson, Sebastian Stan, Charles Dance, Brian Tyree Henry, and Sebastian Koch, alongside returning stars Colin Farrell, Jeffrey Wright, and Andy Serkis.

The sequel is expected to follow the events of The Penguin, continuing Reeves’ grounded Gotham crime saga. Production began in London in June 2026 but was temporarily paused in October as Reeves stepped away to focus on a family matter. Steven Soderbergh has reportedly stepped in to help complete filming. The movie is currently scheduled to hit theaters on February 18, 2028.

As for the villains, the studio has yet to officially reveal the full lineup—meaning fans may have to wait a little longer before Gotham’s secrets are truly out of the bag.

‘The Batman Part II’ Halts Filming Following Unfortunate On-set Cast Accident

What do you think about the alleged leaks? Let us know in the comments.